Here is why property prices are going to climb in 2025 in Indianapolis

Our industry specialist has reviewed and approved the final article. Also, some of the data presented here have been integrated into the Indianapolis real estate spreadsheet template.

Thinking of buying in Indianapolis? Get our financial spreadsheet tailored to this specific market.

Expecting a dip in Indianapolis property prices in 2025? Think again.

Despite economic shifts, the Indianapolis market is poised for growth, with increasing demand and limited housing supply driving prices up.

In this blog post, we will explore why property prices in this city are set to rise in 2025.

We rely on solid, up-to-date data and statistics from multiple credible sources, ensuring our analysis is grounded in fact, not speculation.

By thoroughly examining this data, we arrive at our own well-informed conclusions, which we share with you at the end. Enjoy the read!

This article gives you valuable insights, but remember, it’s not and will never be investment advice. We pull data from a range of sources to provide you with the most accurate picture possible, yet we can’t guarantee complete accuracy. Markets are difficult to predict. Make sure to do your own research and consult a professional before making any financial moves. Any risks or losses are your own responsibility.

1) In Indianapolis, there are only about 0.45 homes for each person, which is quite limited

Signal strength: strong

The fact that there is around 0.45 home per inhabitant in Indianapolis suggests a limited housing supply relative to the population.

When housing supply is limited, it often leads to increased competition among buyers, which can drive up prices. In Indianapolis, this ratio is considered low because the national average is typically higher, indicating a tighter market.

One local factor contributing to this is the growing demand from young professionals attracted by the city's expanding tech and healthcare sectors. This influx of new residents can further strain the housing supply, leading to higher demand and potentially rising prices.

If the ratio were to increase significantly, say to 0.6 home per inhabitant, it might suggest a more balanced market, potentially stabilizing prices.

Source: USCensus

2) Redfin considers the Indianapolis real estate market to be "very competitive"

Signal strength: strong

The fact that Redfin ranks the Indianapolis real estate market as "very competitive" is a strong indicator that housing prices are likely to rise in 2025.

When a market is labeled as "very competitive," it means that there is a high demand for homes, often leading to multiple offers and quick sales. In Indianapolis, the most competitive properties are single-family homes located in suburban areas, which are highly sought after by families looking for more space and a quieter environment.

These suburban areas offer good schools, parks, and community amenities, making them attractive to buyers who prioritize quality of life. As more people seek these types of properties, the demand increases, which typically drives up prices.

If the market were to become "less competitive," with fewer buyers and longer time on the market for homes, it could signal a potential stabilization or decrease in housing prices.

Source: Redfin

3) Indianapolis home values have risen by 6.0% since last year, and this trend could persist

Signal strength: strong

The fact that home values in Indianapolis have already changed by 6.0% since last year is a strong indicator that the housing market is on an upward trend. This increase suggests that demand is growing, which often leads to higher prices.

Currently, the median home price in Indianapolis is around $225,605, and this figure is likely to rise if the trend continues. Additionally, the median sales price per square foot is around $139, which reflects the value buyers are willing to pay for space in this market.

These statistics show that the market is healthy and potentially lucrative for investors. If the current growth rate persists, it could mean even higher returns on investment in the future.

However, if the growth rate were to drop significantly, it might indicate a cooling market, which would challenge the assumption of rising prices.

Source: Redfin

4) Three major websites predict that home prices in Indianapolis will rise in 2025

Signal strength: strong

There are three major websites forecasting a positive growth for home prices in Indianapolis in 2025, which is a promising signal for potential investors.

Among these forecasts, Realtor is the most optimistic with an expected increase of 8.20% in home prices, followed by Redfin at 4%, and finally Zillow with a more conservative estimate of 1.40%. This significant gap in forecasts suggests varying levels of confidence and assumptions about the market conditions.

While these predictions are encouraging, it's important to remember that forecasts should be taken with caution as they are based on models that may not account for unforeseen changes. Therefore, we will also rely on strong, reliable, and actual data to make a well-informed professional judgment.

If these forecasts were to predict a negative growth or decline in home prices, it would signal a potential downturn in the market.

Sources: ZillowForecasts, RedfinForecasts, RealtorForecasts

5) In Indianapolis, a local can buy a house in about 3.4 years, which is relatively quick

Signal strength: moderate

In Indianapolis, it currently takes around 3.4 years for a local to afford a house, which is relatively short compared to many other cities.

This short time frame suggests that housing is still quite affordable for the average resident, making it an attractive market for potential buyers. With a median household income of approximately $66,629, residents have a decent purchasing power.

Meanwhile, the median home price is about $225,605, which aligns well with the income levels, indicating a balanced market. This balance suggests that as demand increases, prices are likely to rise in the near future, possibly by 2025.

If the time to afford a house were to increase to over 5 years, it might indicate that the market is becoming less affordable, potentially slowing down price growth.

Source: USCensus

6) Indianapolis boasts a solid "Livability" score of 76, indicating a good quality of life

Signal strength: moderate

The livability score of 76 in Indianapolis is considered good because it reflects a balance of factors that make the city attractive to residents.

One key aspect is the affordable cost of living, which is lower than many other major cities, making it appealing for families and young professionals. Additionally, Indianapolis boasts a vibrant cultural scene with numerous museums, theaters, and music venues that enhance the quality of life.

Moreover, the city has a strong sense of community, with numerous local events and festivals that bring people together, fostering a welcoming environment. These factors contribute to the assumption that housing demand will increase as more people are drawn to the area, potentially driving up prices in 2025.

However, if the livability score were to drop below 70, it might indicate declining conditions, which could deter potential buyers and investors.

Source: AreaVibes

7) Indianapolis offers homes at prices 48% lower than the national average

Signal strength: minimal

The fact that Indianapolis has a median home price 48% below the national average suggests that there is significant room for growth in the housing market. This gap indicates that Indianapolis is an attractive option for buyers who are priced out of more expensive markets, potentially driving demand and prices up.

In Indianapolis, the most expensive properties are likely to be luxury homes located in areas like Meridian-Kessler, where historic charm and proximity to amenities attract higher prices. On the other hand, the cheapest properties are often small, older homes in neighborhoods like Martindale-Brightwood, which are still undergoing revitalization.

As demand increases, these lower-priced areas may see significant appreciation as investors and homebuyers seek more affordable options. This trend could lead to a rise in overall housing prices in the city.

If the median home price in Indianapolis were to rise to match or exceed the national average, it might suggest that the market has reached a saturation point, potentially slowing further price increases.

Source: Zillow

8) Indianapolis boasts a strong employment rate of 66.7%

Signal strength: minimal

The employment rate in Indianapolis is at 66.7%, which is considered high compared to the national average in the United States. This high employment rate indicates a strong local economy, which often leads to increased demand for housing as more people have stable incomes and can afford to buy homes.

In Indianapolis, the three major employment sectors are healthcare, manufacturing, and technology. Companies like Eli Lilly and Company in the healthcare sector and Rolls-Royce in manufacturing employ a significant number of people, contributing to the city's economic stability.

As these sectors continue to thrive, they attract more workers to the area, further boosting the demand for housing. This increased demand, coupled with a limited supply of homes, is likely to drive up housing prices in 2025.

If the employment rate were to drop below 60%, it might signal economic challenges, potentially leading to a decrease in housing demand and stabilizing or lowering prices.

Sources: USCensus, DataUSA

9) In Indianapolis, about a quarter of homes sell for more than their listing price

Signal strength: minimal

In Indianapolis, around 25% of sales close at a price higher than the listing price, which is a strong indicator of demand. When buyers are willing to pay more than the asking price, it often means that competition among buyers is intense, driving prices upward.

This trend suggests that the housing market is experiencing a shortage of available homes, as buyers are eager to secure properties even at a premium. As demand continues to outpace supply, home prices are likely to increase as buyers compete for limited inventory.

For potential investors, this is a signal that investing in Indianapolis real estate could yield profitable returns in the future. However, if the percentage of sales closing above the listing price were to drop significantly, say to below 10%, it might indicate a cooling market.

Source: Zillow

10) In Indianapolis, home prices have risen by an average of 7.8% annually over the past decade

Signal strength: minimal

The fact that home prices in Indianapolis have appreciated at an average rate of 7.8% over the last decade is a strong indicator of a healthy real estate market. This consistent growth suggests that there has been sustained demand and increasing property values, which are positive signs for potential investors.

While this historical data points to a favorable trend, it's important to remember that past performance doesn't guarantee future results. However, such a track record can still be a valuable indicator when assessing future market conditions, as it reflects a pattern of growth.

Investors should consider this data as part of a broader analysis, keeping in mind that other economic factors and market dynamics also play a crucial role. If the appreciation rate were to drop significantly, say below 2% annually over a few years, it might suggest a shift in the market trend.

Source: NeighborhoodScout

So, are prices going to climb in 2025 in Indianapolis? Yes, they are!